Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Deciding between the Xbox 360 and PS3 is about player preference

I recently responded to a question on Yahoo! Answers about which console is superior between Microsoft's Xbox 360 and Sony's Playstation 3 (sorry Nintendo).

Below is my response to the ever-debated issue that may help others seeking the same question:

Question:
Which is better Xbox 360 or PS3? In games, graphics, online, website, accessories and technology. I have a Xbox 360 but I want other peoples ideas.


Answer:
The answer to that question is strictly based on player preference. However, the easiest signifier (since many games are available on both platforms) is the Blu-ray component. The Playstation 3 acts as an integrated platform via its built-in Blu-ray player and free browser. However, if you already own a Blu-ray player, it might be better to stick with the Xbox 360 since you will be using the console solely as a video game console. However, it may be more convenient for gamers who want more functionality to purchase the more pricey PS3.

Next, I will compare both to each of your categories:

Games

Both the 360 and PS3 have comparable libraries of titles. The Xbox 360 has most notably the "Halo" and "Gears of War" series as well as RPG titles such as "Fable" and "Mass Effect." The PS3 has exclusive titles such as "Resistance," "Little Big Planet," and "Metal Gear Solid 4." It is up to which games most appeal to you.


Graphics

Despite Sony's "cell processor" in the Playstation 3 it is hard to distinguish between both consoles which is more visually superior. However, since PS3 games are Blu-ray based, there is more leeway for available space in each game which could be used for updated visuals and more detailed environments. Nevertheless, several games are developed for the Xbox 360 and directly ported to the PS3 which nullifies that advantage.


Online/Network

Xbox Live is the more fully established and widely popular of the two online networks. However, there is a subscription fee to use Xbox Live. The Playstation Network is free for PS3 users and the PS3 has a built-in browser - I believe 360 users have to have an Xbox Live Gold membership to use a browser. I would certainly give an edge to the Playstation 3 since it is ridiculous to pay to use your internet connection.


Accessories

Personally, I care more about the games and not so much on the accessories. I will tell you that you have to purchase "accessories" for the Xbox 360 in order to recharge your controller (otherwise, you are reusing batteries) and you need to drop about $100 for the Xbox 360 to be connected to a wireless network. Both of these options come standard on the Playstation 3. However, Microsoft's "Natal" peripheral is likely to be a game changer since the camera will allow you to control games via movement in 3D space. Check out my source link for a full description on the Natal and Sony's new motion sensor controller.


Technology

This reverts to some of my previous comments on what is built into the Playstation 3 and what you have to purchase separately on the Xbox 360. However, if you did not need or want any of these extra features, it might be worth it to opt for the cheaper Xbox 360.


Got a question about video games? Need an answer? Just submit a comment and have your questions answered right here on VGF.

No comments: